Fate Cakes
614.219.9429
1360 Cherry Bottom Road
Wed: 9AM-2PM
Thur/Fri: 9AM-5PM
Sat: 9AM-2PM
Sun-Tues: CLOSED
Order Online
- Delivery - DoorDash
- Pickup
- Schedule A Cake Tasting
- My Cart
- Checkout
For a smooth and elegant finish, custom created buttercream cakes are your answer. We’re baking / designing cakes and customizing to your party’s specific theme. Let us a gorgeously displayed cake that will both be delicious and a vision that is social-worthy. Some prefer the modern look of fondant but others would prefer a product with a better tasting icing/topping. We invent gourmet cakes with both buttercream and fondant and we can style a cake to the design and icing of your choice.
Order Information: Please contact our design team to discuss accurate pricing on all custom cakes. Below is a list of our standard pricing. Additional customization to your order may increase the total price.
PLEASE ALLOW A TWO WEEK MINIMUM (ONE WEEK FROM PAYMENT) FOR ANY CAKE ORDER. YOU CAN TEXT US WITH YOUR INFORMATION AND ANY PHOTO INSPIRATION OR QUESTIONS (614-219-9429)
Below is the starting price for all single (non-tiered) cakes. Additional pricing applied for custom designs.
A single (non tiered cake) is 2-layers of cake and stands aprox. 5″ tall. (3-Layers are available in both 6″ and 8″ and are aprox. 6.5″ tall)
| Circle Cake Size | Servings | Price |
| 4″ | 4-6 | $29.50 |
| 6″ | 8-12 | $41.50 |
| 6″ (3 Layer) | 16-18 | $71.00 |
| 8″ | 16-24 | $79.00 |
| 8″ (3-Layer) | 30-38 | $110.50 |
| 9″ | 20-30 | $98.75 |
| 10″ | 20-38 | $138.25 |
| 12” | 36-50 | $166.00 |
| 14” | 50-70 | $237.00 |
| 16” | 65-90 | $296.15 |
| Square Cake Size | Servings | Price |
| 6″ | 9 | $42.50 |
| 8″ | 16 | $71.00 |
| 10″ | 25 | $111.00 |
| 12” | 36 | $160.00 |
| Sheet Cake Size | Servings | Price |
| 1/4 Sheet | 25 | $62.50 |
| 1/2 Sheet | 50 | $125.00 |
| *A sheet cake is one layer of cake with icing on top and sides. |
A tiered cake is multiple single cakes stacked on top of each other. Each separate cake includes 2-layers of cake and each separate cake stands aprox. 5″ tall.
Circle |
||
| Two Tiered – (Circle) | Servings | Price |
| 4″ / 6″ | 12-18 | $81.00 |
| 4″ / 8″ | 20-30 | $133.50 |
| 6″ / 8″ | 24-36 | $155.75 |
| 6″ / 9″ | 28-42 | $186.00 |
| 6″ / 10″ | 38-50 | $222.25 |
| 8″ / 10″ | 46-62 | $276.00 |
| 8″ / 12″ | 52-74 | $329.00 |
| 9″ / 12″ | 56-80 | $356.00 |
| Three Tiered – (Circle) | Servings | Price |
| 4″ / 6″ / 8″ | 28-42 | $208.00 |
| 4″ / 8″ / 10″ | 42-68 | $305.00 |
| 4″ / 8″ / 12″ | 56-80 | $396.50 |
| 6″ / 8″ / 10″ | 54-88 | $435.00 |
| 6″ / 9″ / 12″ | 64-92 | $455.50 |
| 8″ / 10″ / 12″ | 82-112 | $554.00 |
| 6″ / 10″ / 14″ | 88-120 | $594.50 |
| 8″ / 12″ / 16″ | 117-164 | $881.00 |
| Four Tiered – (Circle) | Servings | Pricing |
| 4″ / 6″ / 8″ / 10″ | 58-80 | $428.00 |
| 4″ / 6″ / 8″ / 14″ | 78-112 | $590.25 |
| 6″ / 8″ / 10″ / 12″ | 90-130 | $691.00 |
| 6″ / 8″ / 10″ / 14″ | 104-150 | $795.00 |
| 8″ / 10″ / 12″ / 14″ | 132-182 | $973.75 |
| 8″ / 12″ / 14″ / 16” | 167-234 | $1,249.00 |
| * Please note: 4 Tiered Cakes are only available for delivery at this time |
The following flavor options are for single or tiered cakes ONLY. Scroll down to see options for sheet/number/letter/carved 2D/3D cake and icing flavors.
| Cake Flavors | Whipped Icing Flavors | Purée Fruit Filling Flavors |
| Vanilla | Vanilla | Raspberry |
| Chocolate | Chocolate | Strawberry |
| Lemon Poppy | Peanut Butter | |
| Almond | Oreo | |
| Oreo | ||
| Strawberry | ||
| Funfetti* | *Not included in cake tastings | |
| Marble* | *Not included in cake tastings |
Sheet Cake / Number Cake / Letter Cake / Carved Cake / 2D Cake / 3D Options (Sheet cakes, carved cakes, 2D and most 3D cakes are not layered/torted)
| Cake Flavors | Icing Flavors |
| Vanilla | Vanilla |
| Chocolate | Chocolate |
Fate Cakes
614.219.9429
1360 Cherry Bottom Road
Wed: 9AM-2PM
Thur/Fri: 9AM-5PM
Sat: 9AM-2PM
Sun-Tues: CLOSED