Customized Cakes
Hosting a unique party and needing a cake that fits the theme? Let’s get started and create a perfect cake for that special occasion!
Hosting a unique party and needing a cake that fits the theme? Let’s get started and create a perfect cake for that special occasion!
PLEASE ALLOW A two WEEK MINIMUM (FROM PAYMENT) FOR ANY CAKE ORDER. YOU CAN TEXT US WITH YOUR INFORMATION AND ANY PHOTO INSPIRATION OR QUESTIONS (614-219-9429)
Order Information: Please contact to discuss accurate pricing on all custom cakes. Below is the starting base price for all cake sizes (i.e. cake with smooth icing, icing border and writing is considered a standard cake). Cake examples on this page/website gallery/social media are not listed below and are considered custom designs. Additional pricing applied for custom designs may include, but not limited to: fondant decorations, plastic decorations, hand drawn/carved items, printed images, candies/chocolates, artificial flowers, etc.
A single (non tiered cake) is 2-layers of cake and stands aprox. 5″ tall. (3-Layers are available in both 6″ and 8″ and are aprox. 6.5″ tall)
| Circle Cake Size | Servings | Price |
| 4″ | 4-6 | Starts at $29.50 |
| 6″ | 8-12 | Starts at $41.50 |
| 6″ (3 Layer) | 16-18 | Starts at $71.00 |
| 8″ | 16-24 | Starts at $79.00 |
| 8″ (3-Layer) | 30-38 | Starts at $110.50 |
| 9″ | 20-30 | Starts at $98.75 |
| 10″ | 20-38 | Starts at $138.25 |
| 12” | 36-50 | Starts at $166.00 |
| 14” | 50-70 | Starts at $237.00 |
| 16” | 65-90 | Starts at $296.15 |
| Square Cake Size | Servings | Price |
| 6″ | 9 | Starts at $42.50 |
| 8″ | 16 | Starts at $71.00 |
| 10″ | 25 | Starts at $111.00 |
| 12” | 36 | Starts at $160.00 |
| Sheet Cake Size | Servings | Price |
| 1/4 Sheet | 25 | Starts at $62.50 |
| 1/2 Sheet | 50 | Starts at $125.00 |
| *A sheet cake is one layer of cake with icing on top and sides. |
A tiered cake is multiple single cakes stacked on top of each other. Each separate cake includes 2-layers of cake and each separate cake stands aprox. 5″ tall.
Circle |
||
| Two Tiered – (Circle) | Servings | Price |
| 4″ / 6″ | 12-18 | Starts at $81.00 |
| 4″ / 8″ | 20-30 | Starts at $133.50 |
| 6″ / 8″ | 24-36 | Starts at $155.75 |
| 6″ / 9″ | 28-42 | Starts at $186.00 |
| 6″ / 10″ | 38-50 | Starts at $222.25 |
| 8″ / 10″ | 46-62 | Starts at $276.00 |
| 8″ / 12″ | 52-74 | Starts at $329.00 |
| 9″ / 12″ | 56-80 | Starts at $356.00 |
| Three Tiered – (Circle) | Servings | Price |
| 4″ / 6″ / 8″ | 28-42 | Starts at $208.00 |
| 4″ / 8″ / 10″ | 42-68 | Starts at $305.00 |
| 4″ / 8″ / 12″ | 56-80 | Starts at $396.50 |
| 6″ / 8″ / 10″ | 54-88 | Starts at $435.00 |
| 6″ / 9″ / 12″ | 64-92 | Starts at $455.50 |
| 8″ / 10″ / 12″ | 82-112 | Starts at $554.00 |
| 6″ / 10″ / 14″ | 88-120 | Starts at $594.50 |
| 8″ / 12″ / 16″ | 117-164 | Starts at $881.00 |
| Four Tiered – (Circle) | Servings | Pricing |
| 4″ / 6″ / 8″ / 10″ | 58-80 | Starts at $428.00 |
| 4″ / 6″ / 8″ / 14″ | 78-112 | Starts at $590.25 |
| 6″ / 8″ / 10″ / 12″ | 90-130 | Starts at $691.00 |
| 6″ / 8″ / 10″ / 14″ | 104-150 | Starts at $795.00 |
| 8″ / 10″ / 12″ / 14″ | 132-182 | Starts at $973.75 |
| 8″ / 12″ / 14″ / 16” | 167-234 | Starts at $1,249.00 |
| * Please note: 4 Tiered Cakes are only available for delivery at this time |
Number / Letter and carved cakes have two layers of cake. Carved cakes are one layer of cake with icing on top/sides (Similar to a sheet cake). 3D cakes may have multiple layers of cake depending design
| Number/Letter Cakes | Servings | Price |
| Each Number/Letter | 20 | Starts at $85.00 (Includes silk flowers, chocolates, and sprinkles. Additional pricing may apply) |
| Heart Shaped Cakes | Servings | Price |
| Small | 12 | Starts at $74.00 (Base starting price. Many heart shaped cake prices are determined by design) |
| Large | 30 | Starts at $142.00 (Base starting price. Many heart shaped cake prices are determined by design) |
| Carved Cakes | Servings | Price |
| Each Design | 20-40 | Starts at $85.00-$120.00 (Includes silk flowers, chocolates, and sprinkles. Additional pricing may apply) |
| 2D Cakes | Servings | Price |
| Each Design | 20-40 | Starts at Starts at $9.00/serving. Pricing is determined by design, customization, and fondant details |
| 3D Cakes | Servings | Price |
| Each Design | 10-30 | Starts at Starts at $15.00/serving. Pricing is determined by design, customization, and fondant details |
| Cake Flavors | Whipped Icing Flavors | Purée Fruit Filling Flavors |
| Vanilla | Vanilla | Raspberry |
| Chocolate | Chocolate | Strawberry |
| Lemon Poppy | Peanut Butter | |
| Almond | Oreo | |
| Oreo | ||
| Strawberry | ||
| Funfetti* | *Not included in cake tastings | |
| Marble* | *Not included in cake tastings |
| Cake Flavors | Icing Flavors |
| Vanilla | Vanilla |
| Chocolate | Chocolate |
Local delivery is available for tiered cakes on Saturdays only. Availability is limited based on date. General delivery window is 2:30PM-5:00PM with no specific time request and arrival is anytime during that general window.
Delivery radius is any location within 5-10 miles outside the Columbus 1-270 Outerbelt and pricing is determined on location from our bakery.
Fate Cakes
614.219.9429
1360 Cherry Bottom Road
Wed: 9AM-2PM
Thur/Fri: 9AM-5PM
Sat: 9AM-2PM
Sun-Tues: CLOSED